website website
Skip to content

Shop By Feel

Finding the right comfort level is one of the most important considerations for a new bed. Take a look at what sets each mattress firmness category apart, as well as which comfort level suits which sleepers best.

Firm & Extra Firm Mattress

Firm and extra firm mattresses are constructed with a focus on durable support layers but can still have extra cushioning top layers. Tight-Top beds are thinner, while Euro-Top beds have an additional top layer. Firm mattresses are available in a variety of mattress types, including innerspring, all foam, latex and hybrid.

Who is a firm mattress good for?
Great for back sleepers and stomach sleepers who prefer to have a firmer sleep surface to properly support their bodies. Firm mattresses are for people who want a stable, supportive feel, but also want the option to add extra cushioning in the form of a plush mattress topper for extra comfort.

Best Selling Firm Mattresses

Puffy Mattress Topper - Mattress Brands Puffy bedding
Puffy Mattress Topper - Mattress Brands Puffy bedding
Puffy Mattress Topper - Mattress Brands Puffy bedding
Puffy Mattress Topper - Mattress Brands Puffy bedding
Puffy Mattress Topper - Mattress Brands Puffy bedding
Puffy Mattress Topper - Mattress Brands Puffy bedding

Puffy™ Delux Mattress Topper

$152.00
Brooklyn Bedding™ - Plank Firm Natural: 2-Sided Mattress 10
Brooklyn Bedding™ - Plank Firm Natural: 2-Sided Mattress 10
Brooklyn Bedding™ - Plank Firm Natural: 2-Sided Mattress 10
Brooklyn Bedding™ - Plank Firm Natural: 2-Sided Mattress 10
Brooklyn Bedding™ - Plank Firm Natural: 2-Sided Mattress 10
Brooklyn Bedding™ - Plank Firm Natural: 2-Sided Mattress 10
Brooklyn Bedding™ - Plank Firm Natural: 2-Sided Mattress 10
Brooklyn Bedding™ - Plank Firm Natural: 2-Sided Mattress 10
Brooklyn Bedding™ - Plank Firm Natural: 2-Sided Mattress 10

Brooklyn Bedding™ - Plank Firm Natural: 2-Sided Mattress 10"

$979.00
Brooklyn Bedding™ Plank Firm Luxe: 2-Sided Mattress w/ GlaxioTex Cooling Cover 13.25
Brooklyn Bedding™ Plank Firm Luxe: 2-Sided Mattress w/ GlaxioTex Cooling Cover 13.25
Brooklyn Bedding™ Plank Firm Luxe: 2-Sided Mattress w/ GlaxioTex Cooling Cover 13.25
Brooklyn Bedding™ Plank Firm Luxe: 2-Sided Mattress w/ GlaxioTex Cooling Cover 13.25
Brooklyn Bedding™ Plank Firm Luxe: 2-Sided Mattress w/ GlaxioTex Cooling Cover 13.25
Brooklyn Bedding™ Plank Firm Luxe: 2-Sided Mattress w/ GlaxioTex Cooling Cover 13.25
Brooklyn Bedding™ Plank Firm Luxe: 2-Sided Mattress w/ GlaxioTex Cooling Cover 13.25

Brooklyn Bedding™ Plank Firm Luxe: 2-Sided Mattress w/ GlaxioTex Cooling Cover 13.25"

$768.00
Bear™ Elite Hybrid Mattress 14
Bear™ Elite Hybrid Mattress 14
Bear™ Elite Hybrid Mattress 14
Bear™ Elite Hybrid Mattress 14
Bear™ Elite Hybrid Mattress 14
Bear™ Elite Hybrid Mattress 14
Bear™ Elite Hybrid Mattress 14
Bear™ Elite Hybrid Mattress 14
Bear™ Elite Hybrid Mattress 14

Bear™ Elite Hybrid Mattress 14" (3 Firmness Options)

$1,231.00
Birch™ Kids Natural Mattress 8
Birch™ Kids Natural Mattress 8
Birch™ Kids Natural Mattress 8
Birch™ Kids Natural Mattress 8
Birch™ Kids Natural Mattress 8
Birch™ Kids Natural Mattress 8
Birch™ Kids Natural Mattress 8
Birch™ Kids Natural Mattress 8
Birch™ Kids Natural Mattress 8
Birch™ Kids Natural Mattress 8
Birch™ Kids Natural Mattress 8
Birch™ Kids Natural Mattress 8

Birch™ Kids Natural Mattress 8"

$842.00
Helix™ KIDS 8
Helix™ KIDS 8
Helix™ KIDS 8
Helix™ KIDS 8
Helix™ KIDS 8
Helix™ KIDS 8
Helix™ KIDS 8

Helix™ KIDS 8" Double-Sided Mattress

$599.00
Nolah™ Evolution 15
Nolah™ Evolution 15
Nolah™ Evolution 15
Nolah™ Evolution 15
Nolah™ Evolution 15
Nolah™ Evolution 15
Nolah™ Evolution 15
Nolah™ Evolution 15
Nolah™ Evolution 15
Nolah™ Evolution 15

Nolah™ Evolution 15" - 3 Firmness Options

$974.00
I Love Mattress™ OUT COLD PERFECT FIT™ 13
I Love Mattress™ OUT COLD PERFECT FIT™ 13
I Love Mattress™ OUT COLD PERFECT FIT™ 13
I Love Mattress™ OUT COLD PERFECT FIT™ 13
I Love Mattress™ OUT COLD PERFECT FIT™ 13
I Love Mattress™ OUT COLD PERFECT FIT™ 13

I Love Mattress™ OUT COLD PERFECT FIT™ 13"

$949.00

Medium Mattress

Made in the widest array of materials and constructions, medium comfort mattresses have the largest variability of firmness. These mattresses often are available in several comfort subcategories, including medium-firm, medium-plush and luxury-firm.

Who is a Medium mattress good for?
Medium comfort mattresses are great for all sleeper types, including back sleepers, side sleepers and stomach sleepers. For people who have back pain, a medium firm mattress can help provide the best rest with a combination of support and comfort layers. Medium mattresses are also good for people who do not specifically require either the firmest or softest mattress.

Best Selling Medium Mattresses

Helix™ Midnight Luxe 13.5” Mattress W/ GlacioTex™ Cooling Pillowtop Cover Helix
Helix™ Midnight Luxe 13.5” Mattress W/ GlacioTex™ Cooling Pillowtop Cover Helix
Helix™ Midnight Luxe 13.5” Mattress W/ GlacioTex™ Cooling Pillowtop Cover Helix
Helix™ Midnight Luxe 13.5” Mattress W/ GlacioTex™ Cooling Pillowtop Cover Helix
Helix™ Midnight Luxe 13.5” Mattress W/ GlacioTex™ Cooling Pillowtop Cover Helix
Helix™ Midnight Luxe 13.5” Mattress W/ GlacioTex™ Cooling Pillowtop Cover Helix
Helix™ Midnight Luxe 13.5” Mattress W/ GlacioTex™ Cooling Pillowtop Cover Helix

Helix™ Midnight Luxe 13.5” Mattress W/ GlacioTex™ Cooling Pillowtop Cover (Medium)

$1,229.00
Nolah™ Natural 11
Nolah™ Natural 11
Nolah™ Natural 11
Nolah™ Natural 11
Nolah™ Natural 11
Nolah™ Natural 11
Nolah™ Natural 11
Nolah™ Natural 11
Nolah™ Natural 11

Nolah™ Natural 11" Hybrid Mattress

$974.00
TEMPUR-PEDIC - Adapt Medium - Mattress Brands Tempurpedic Mattress
TEMPUR-PEDIC - Adapt Medium - Mattress Brands Tempurpedic Mattress
TEMPUR-PEDIC - Adapt Medium - Mattress Brands Tempurpedic Mattress
TEMPUR-PEDIC - Adapt Medium - Mattress Brands Tempurpedic Mattress
TEMPUR-PEDIC - Adapt Medium - Mattress Brands Tempurpedic Mattress
TEMPUR-PEDIC - Adapt Medium - Mattress Brands Tempurpedic Mattress
TEMPUR-PEDIC - Adapt Medium - Mattress Brands Tempurpedic Mattress

TEMPUR-PEDIC - Adapt Medium Mattress 11"

$1,599.00
Leesa™ Legend Chill Hybrid 13.5 Mattress Leesa
Leesa™ Legend Chill Hybrid 13.5 Mattress Leesa
Leesa™ Legend Chill Hybrid 13.5 Mattress Leesa
Leesa™ Legend Chill Hybrid 13.5 Mattress Leesa
Leesa™ Legend Chill Hybrid 13.5 Mattress Leesa
Leesa™ Legend Chill Hybrid 13.5 Mattress Leesa
Leesa™ Legend Chill Hybrid 13.5 Mattress Leesa

Leesa™ Legend Chill Hybrid Mattress 13.5"

$1,469.00
Brooklyn Bedding™ - Aurora Lux Cooling w/ Optional Cloud Pillow Top - 13.25
Brooklyn Bedding™ - Aurora Lux Cooling w/ Optional Cloud Pillow Top - 13.25
Brooklyn Bedding™ - Aurora Lux Cooling w/ Optional Cloud Pillow Top - 13.25
Brooklyn Bedding™ - Aurora Lux Cooling w/ Optional Cloud Pillow Top - 13.25
Brooklyn Bedding™ - Aurora Lux Cooling w/ Optional Cloud Pillow Top - 13.25
Brooklyn Bedding™ - Aurora Lux Cooling w/ Optional Cloud Pillow Top - 13.25
Brooklyn Bedding™ - Aurora Lux Cooling w/ Optional Cloud Pillow Top - 13.25
Brooklyn Bedding™ - Aurora Lux Cooling w/ Optional Cloud Pillow Top - 13.25
Brooklyn Bedding™ - Aurora Lux Cooling w/ Optional Cloud Pillow Top - 13.25

Brooklyn Bedding™ - Aurora Lux Cooling w/ Optional Cloud Pillow Top - 13.25" (3 Firmness Options)

$839.00
Bear™ Elite Hybrid Mattress 14
Bear™ Elite Hybrid Mattress 14
Bear™ Elite Hybrid Mattress 14
Bear™ Elite Hybrid Mattress 14
Bear™ Elite Hybrid Mattress 14
Bear™ Elite Hybrid Mattress 14
Bear™ Elite Hybrid Mattress 14
Bear™ Elite Hybrid Mattress 14
Bear™ Elite Hybrid Mattress 14

Bear™ Elite Hybrid Mattress 14" (3 Firmness Options)

$1,231.00
Birch™ Natural Hybrid Mattress 11
Birch™ Natural Hybrid Mattress 11
Birch™ Natural Hybrid Mattress 11
Birch™ Natural Hybrid Mattress 11
Birch™ Natural Hybrid Mattress 11
Birch™ Natural Hybrid Mattress 11
Birch™ Natural Hybrid Mattress 11
Birch™ Natural Hybrid Mattress 11

Birch™ Natural Hybrid Mattress 11"

$1,124.00
Leesa™ Oasis Chill Hybrid Mattress 13.5
Leesa™ Oasis Chill Hybrid Mattress 13.5
Leesa™ Oasis Chill Hybrid Mattress 13.5
Leesa™ Oasis Chill Hybrid Mattress 13.5
Leesa™ Oasis Chill Hybrid Mattress 13.5
Leesa™ Oasis Chill Hybrid Mattress 13.5
Leesa™ Oasis Chill Hybrid Mattress 13.5

Leesa™ Oasis Chill Hybrid Mattress 13.5"

$881.00

Plush & Extra Plush Mattress

Plush mattresses have multiple layers of cushioning foam for ultimate comfort on top of a supportive core and as a result are usually thicker mattresses. They are available in multiple mattress construction types, from memory foam to hybrid to innerspring. Pillow top and Euro top mattresses often fall into the plush comfort category.

Who is a Plush mattress good for?
Plush mattresses are the best for side sleepers because the extra comfort layers help cradle the curves of the body for a restful night’s sleep. They give excellent support to lighter sleepers and can help provide relief for sleepers prone to uncomfortable pressure points or joint pain.

Best Selling Plush Mattresses

Nectar Premier Hybrid Mattress - Mattress Brands Nectar Mattress
Nectar Premier Hybrid Mattress - Mattress Brands Nectar Mattress
Nectar Premier Hybrid Mattress - Mattress Brands Nectar Mattress
Nectar Premier Hybrid Mattress - Mattress Brands Nectar Mattress
Nectar Premier Hybrid Mattress - Mattress Brands Nectar Mattress
Nectar Premier Hybrid Mattress - Mattress Brands Nectar Mattress

Nectar® Premier Hybrid Mattress 13"

$799.00
Puffy™ Diamond Mattress (Hybrid) 16
Puffy™ Diamond Mattress (Hybrid) 16
Puffy™ Diamond Mattress (Hybrid) 16
Puffy™ Diamond Mattress (Hybrid) 16
Puffy™ Diamond Mattress (Hybrid) 16
Puffy™ Diamond Mattress (Hybrid) 16

Puffy™ Diamond Mattress (Hybrid) 16"

$1,999.00
The DreamCloud Premier Rest - Mattress Brands DreamCloud Mattress
The DreamCloud Premier Rest - Mattress Brands DreamCloud Mattress
The DreamCloud Premier Rest 16
The DreamCloud Premier Rest - Mattress Brands DreamCloud Mattress
The DreamCloud Premier Rest - Mattress Brands DreamCloud Mattress
The DreamCloud Premier Rest - Mattress Brands DreamCloud Mattress
The DreamCloud Premier Rest - Mattress Brands DreamCloud Mattress

The DreamCloud Premier Rest Mattress 16" Height

$924.00
TEMPUR-PEDIC - LuxeAdapt Soft - Mattress Brands Tempurpedic Mattress
TEMPUR-PEDIC - LuxeAdapt Soft - Mattress Brands Tempurpedic Mattress
TEMPUR-PEDIC - LuxeAdapt Soft - Mattress Brands Tempurpedic Mattress
TEMPUR-PEDIC - LuxeAdapt Soft - Mattress Brands Tempurpedic Mattress
TEMPUR-PEDIC - LuxeAdapt Soft - Mattress Brands Tempurpedic Mattress
TEMPUR-PEDIC - LuxeAdapt Soft - Mattress Brands Tempurpedic Mattress

TEMPUR-PEDIC - LuxeAdapt Soft 13"

$3,399.00
Puffy Royal Mattress - Mattress Brands Puffy Mattress
Puffy Royal Mattress - Mattress Brands Puffy Mattress
Puffy Royal Mattress - Mattress Brands Puffy Mattress
Puffy Royal Mattress - Mattress Brands Puffy Mattress
Puffy Royal Mattress - Mattress Brands Puffy Mattress
Puffy Royal Mattress - Mattress Brands Puffy Mattress
Puffy Royal Mattress - Mattress Brands Puffy Mattress

Puffy™ Royal Mattress 14"

$1,349.00
Awara Premier Natural Hybrid Mattress 12
Awara Premier Natural Hybrid Mattress 12
Awara Premier Natural Hybrid Mattress 12
Awara Premier Natural Hybrid Mattress - Mattress Brands Awara Mattresses
Awara Premier Natural Hybrid Mattress 12
Awara Premier Natural Hybrid Mattress - Mattress Brands Awara Mattresses
Awara Premier Natural Hybrid Mattress - Mattress Brands Awara Mattresses

Awara Premier Natural Hybrid Mattress 12"

$1,099.00

Compare products

{"one"=>"Select 2 or 3 items to compare", "other"=>"{{ count }} of 3 items selected"}

Select first item to compare

Select second item to compare

Select third item to compare

Compare